I know a lot of things
I know a lot of things
But I don’t know you
– Mannequin Pussy, “I Don’t Know You”
It’s the end of Psycho. Norman Bates is at the police station, freshly caught for murder. He’s alone in the interrogation room pondering his predicament when a fly lands on his hand. He thinks in his mother’s voice, “They’re probably watching me. Well let them. Let them see what kind of a person I am. I’m not even going to swat that fly. I hope they are watching. They’ll see. They’ll see and they’ll know and they’ll say, ‘Why she wouldn’t even harm a fly.’”
[Have you taken this test before? It’s not a good one. If you pass, you’re safe. If you fail?]
Elizabeth Holmes stares up at Nathan Fielder. A close-up on her default smile and wide eyes. “It took me a really long time to be okay with, um, with letting someone see me cry.” She stares. Blinks. A tear rolls down her face. Her smile does not falter. You can almost hear the fly.
The group chat is buzzing. All three players have seen the movie now and we’re chewing everything in sight. How much effort went into fumigating her guilt.
Would we even be having this discussion if she was not a white blonde woman with gigantic blue eyes. Would she have been allowed to delay her prison sentence with pregnancy if not for that fact.
Billy was for sure abusing Adderall/uppers the entire time.
Then addiction could play into why she attracted him. Nathan had a gambling problem at one point.
People have referenced her ability to seemingly make men feel like they are the only person in the room
I didn’t know shit about Elizabeth Holmes until this documentary. Never heard of her before in my life. Before I walked into the theater, a friend gave me a rundown of her crimes, but the only reason I bought a ticket was to see the guy who made poop flavored froyo do something serious.
I think the most compelling themes to me are truth vs. belief vs. fact
like what does a liar believe and what responsibility do they have
What responsibility does a liar have? How the hell am I supposed to answer a galaxy brain question like that? If you don’t have any friends who are smarter than you, you really need to get some.
Responsibility to themselves? If Elizabeth’s persona in front of the cameras is that of a confused lamb caught in a storm, and Billy’s portrayal of her on Twitter is a rude bitch, and she does not care about that contradiction, then control over perception may not be her goal.
Then again, I’m reminded of Abed from Community, “When you really know who you are and what you like about yourself, changing for other people isn’t such a big deal.” Obviously, Abed is the good twin in this situation.
Pair that with Frank Gallagher in Shameless whose only goal at any given moment is to be anything but sober. A solid year went by as I made a mantra of Frank’s line, “I am whatever I need to be at the time I need to be it.”
Pair that with Elizabeth Holmes, who’s likely cosplaying her entire personality, and a liar’s responsibility becomes whatever stands between them and their objective. So naturally she wouldn’t care how Billy portrays her. As the evil twin, she is whatever she needs to be at the time she needs to be it.
And what about Nathan? How long are you willing to believe the best of someone?
This is a memory from August, 2019. In a few months, our dog would be dead and we’d be stuck with each other in lockdown.
I’m standing in the living room, which was also the kitchen and my office. My boyfriend (now known as “poop guy” to my friends) is on the small futon playing Dark Souls. He has taken to wearing two sets of headphones at a time. AirPods for podcasts and music, and over-ears for his game. It was really funny the first time. Two pairs at once? Ridiculous!
But now there’s a bandage on his finger from where he cut himself on the dishes. He says it was the big stock pot I made our dinner with, something about how we shouldn’t have dishes that are this sharp.
I go to the sink and grip the pot, run my fingers around the edge to see. Softly, then firmly, you know really get in there. I return to stand in his periphery and he does not acknowledge my stare.
[Are you studying now? These people. You will meet them.]
Why do I care about any of this if Elizabeth is already in prison and the whole thing is “over”? This has no bearing on me or my life. But dammit there were no sheets on that mattress! Was this the first rope around the ankles?
Surely with a life of comedy, Nathan’s been inoculated against bullshit by now. Have I? Would the “I don’t understand” routine have worked on me? Maybe if I can understand these liars I won’t lose next time. That’s why it feels so dangerous watching Nathan move through the days with them, because if the guy who built a career on perception and elaborate scenarios and rehearsals is changed; if he as a character begins the story with confidence and integrity and over the course of the film loses some footing, what the fuck hope do I have?
At the end when he changed his memory for the reenactment script, did he really lose footing, or was he lying too? If he was indeed acting there, if he remembered exactly what she said in prison and chose instead to show us uncertainty, is that not more honest to the type of situation they’re in?
Nathan shows us what it looks like to succumb, the way Elizabeth’s victims fall before her, how it looks and feels to be caught by someone who’s lying to your face 24/7, three sixty five. Here he was at the beginning: committed to the integrity of the film, adamant about best practices and accuracy. A confident man.
Three hours later he’s second guessing himself. Willing to go in the water after all, after a little convincing. The first time we see that shot, the two are so far away it’s hard to tell who’s in the water. Adam Locke-Norton edited this diptych for us as a taster. If you can’t see it fully, can’t make it out, then maybe you’re not really gone yet.
It doesn’t take much for all your defenses to fail one by one. You can call a wolf a wolf and congratulate yourself for being so smart, and still look down to find your ribs scattered in the snow, sucked clean.
Look I’m probably taking this too personally. I’m not Nathan. That’s not me scrambling for my phone waiting for Elizabeth to call so we can have boring small talk. And Nathan isn’t me. He’s not doing the dishes after his boyfriend deliberately sliced himself so he could keep playing my Nintendo Switch. Say what you will about my ex, he really could commit to the bit. A responsibility shared by comedians and liars alike.
So if recent events in my private life have taught me anything, it’s that when someone brings you nothing but confusion, you can simply give up trying to understand them. The confusion is enough of an arrival at the truth. And maybe after all is said and done, it’s more honest if the little lamb doesn’t remain snow white.
Works Cited:
Abbott, Paul. Shameless. TV series, 2013.
Anna, and Jess. Apples in My Eyes. SMS, Nov. 2026.
Mannequin Pussy. “I Don’t Know You.” I Got Heaven, 2024.
Psycho. Directed by Alfred Hitchcock, 1960.
Russo, Anthony. Community. 2010.
You Can See Everything. Directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, 2026.

